Topping D50 Vs Schiit Modi 3: The Battle For Best Budget Dac

In the realm of digital-to-analog converters (DACs), the Topping D50 and the Schiit Modi 3 stand as two highly acclaimed options. Both devices offer exceptional sound quality, but they differ in certain aspects that may influence your choice. This blog post will provide a comprehensive comparison of the Topping D50 vs Schiit Modi 3, exploring their features, performance, and value proposition.

Features

Topping D50:

• Supports up to PCM 32-bit/768kHz and DSD512
• Utilizes two AK4493EQ DAC chips
• Features an XMOS XU208 USB receiver
• Includes a built-in headphone amplifier

Schiit Modi 3:

• Supports up to PCM 24-bit/192kHz and DSD64
• Employs an AK4490EQ DAC chip
• Uses a USB-C input
• Lacks a headphone amplifier

Performance

Sound Quality:

Both the Topping D50 and the Schiit Modi 3 offer excellent sound quality. They provide a wide soundstage, accurate imaging, and a natural tonal balance. However, some users may perceive subtle differences in their sonic characteristics. The D50 is generally considered to have a slightly warmer and more analog-like sound, while the Modi 3 is known for its crisp and detailed presentation.

Technical Measurements:

Objectively, the Topping D50 outperforms the Schiit Modi 3 in terms of technical measurements. It has a lower THD+N and a higher signal-to-noise ratio, indicating a cleaner and more accurate sound reproduction.

Value Proposition

Topping D50:

• Priced at around $250
• Offers a comprehensive feature set, including a headphone amplifier
• Provides exceptional sound quality for its price range

Schiit Modi 3:

• Priced at around $100
• Features a more basic design without a headphone amplifier
• Delivers excellent sound quality at an affordable price

Which One is Right for You?

Choosing between the Topping D50 and the Schiit Modi 3 depends on your specific needs and budget. If you seek a feature-rich DAC with a built-in headphone amplifier and the best possible sound quality, the Topping D50 is the superior choice. However, if your budget is limited or you don’t require a headphone amplifier, the Schiit Modi 3 offers an exceptional value proposition.

Additional Considerations

Headphone Output:

If you plan on using headphones with your DAC, the Topping D50’s built-in headphone amplifier provides a convenient and powerful solution. The Schiit Modi 3 does not have a headphone amplifier, so you will need to purchase an external unit if you want to connect headphones.

USB Input:

The Topping D50 uses an XMOS XU208 USB receiver, while the Schiit Modi 3 utilizes a USB-C input. Both types of USB inputs are widely supported, but the XMOS receiver in the D50 may offer slightly better performance.

Upgradability:

The Topping D50 allows for future upgrades through its USB input. This means that you can potentially improve the sound quality of the D50 by purchasing a higher-quality USB cable or an external USB interface. The Schiit Modi 3 does not offer any upgrade options.

Wrap-Up

Both the Topping D50 and the Schiit Modi 3 are excellent DACs that offer exceptional sound quality for their respective price ranges. The D50 is the better choice if you need a feature-rich DAC with a headphone amplifier, while the Modi 3 is a more affordable option that still delivers great sound. Ultimately, the best DAC for you will depend on your specific needs and budget.

Basics You Wanted To Know

1. Which DAC has a more natural sound signature?

The Topping D50 is generally considered to have a slightly warmer and more analog-like sound than the Schiit Modi 3.

2. Can I use the Schiit Modi 3 with headphones?

No, the Schiit Modi 3 does not have a built-in headphone amplifier. You will need to purchase an external headphone amplifier to use headphones with the Modi 3.

3. Which DAC is better for use with a low-impedance headphone?

The Topping D50’s headphone amplifier is more powerful than the Modi 3’s, making it a better choice for driving low-impedance headphones.